Heterodyne scanning near-field optical microscopy for amplitude and phase measurements

The following results are extracted from the thesis of Antonello Nesci, and the interested reader is directed also to...

Abstract

We present experimental and theoretical studies of optical fields with sub-wavelength features. We intend to gain a better understanding of the interaction of light with microstructures in order to determine their optical properties. An electromagnetic field is characterised by an amplitude, a phase and a polarisation state. Therefore, experimental studies require coherent detection methods, in particular heterodyne scanning probe microscope (heterodyne SNOM), which allow the measurement of amplitude and phase of the optical field with sub-wavelength resolution. We discuss some basic properties of phase distributions. Light waves diffracted by microstructures can give birth to phase dislocations, also called phase singularities. Phase singularities are isolated points where the amplitude of the field is zero. Phase dislocations can be observed in the near- and far-field of optical microstructures, such as gratings. The behaviour of phase singularities have been localised with a spatial resolution of 10 nm. Comparison of the calculated and measured amplitude and phase for the TE- and TM-mode with the heterodyne SNOM gives interesting information about the field conversion by the fibre tip probe. A non-trivial conclusion points out that the three vectorial components of the electric field are detected.

Set-up

In figures 1 to 4, we present a description of the complete optical heterodyne probe system. We show how a heterodyne interferometer has been combined with a scanning probe optical microscope in order to measure amplitude and phase of optical near- and far-fields.

Fig. 1: A plan of the heterodyne system.
Plan of the system

Fig. 1: A laser beam is split into a signal and reference beam. The signal beam passes through two acousto optic modulators, creating an overall frequency difference of 70 kHz between signal and reference. This signal beam then illuminates the sample. The field generated by the sample is probed via the bent fibre tip, controlled using a commercial AFM system. The probed light then passes through a fibre and is combined with the reference, thus generating a beat signal at 70 kHz. This beat signal is detected, and the phase and amplitude extracted electronically.


Figs. 2 and 3: Photographs of the SNOM apparatus.
SNOM apparatus 1 SNOM apparatus 2
Fig. 2 Fig. 3

Fig. 2: The laser beam exits downwards (from gold coloured box). It then passes through the optical chopper (CH) and is split in two (BS). The reference is injected into a fibre. The signal is passed through the two AOMs to shift its frequency, and is then injected into a fibre.
Fig. 3: The signal arrives from the right via the fibre (yellow/green, bottom right). The output passes via some in-line optics and is then directed to illuminate the sample. The optical microscope is used to observe and position the fibre tip and signal illumination relative to the sample. The tip position is controlled via the commercial AFM (blue box, left). The resultant beat signal is measured using the detector seen on the right. A perspex box surrounds this section of the SNOM, which greatly improves stability.


Fig. 4: Detail of two possible illumination configurations.
Direct illumination Frustrated total internal reflection
(a) (b)

Fig. 4: (a) direct illumination normal to sample plane. The light exits the fibre (F), passes through a half-wave plate (H), a polariser (P) and collimating lens. A mirror then reflects this light directly onto the sample.
(b) Frustrated Total Internal Reflection (RTIR). A prism is used to provide an evanescent field for the sample. This evanescent field is perturbed by the presence of the tip, and light then propagates into the tip and the connected signal fibre.


Experimental results on optical evanescent fields

We study the amplitude and the phase of an optical plane wave. In Fig. 5 we can see the constant amplitude (colour scale) and the isophase contour plot.

Fig. 5: Plane-wave measurement.
Plane-wave measurement

Fig. 5: Measurement of a plane wave propagating at a slight angle to the z-axis, towards the fibre tip. This is a real-space scan of the x-z plane, thus requiring combined movement of the tip in both x and z. The tip is assumed to be approximately aligned with the z-axis. Amplitude is time-averaged, and is thus constant for the whole plane. Heavy phase lines indicate multiples of two pi.


The behaviour of an evanescent wave has been studied. In fact, Photon Scanning Tunnelling Microscopy (PSTM) is essentially based on evanescent fields. Frustration of the evanescent field explains why and how the diffraction limit of a conventional optical microscope can be surpassed. 2-D measurements of an evanescent wave are shown in fig. 6 and in fig. 7 (cross-section of the absolute optical power, measured down to the femto-watt level!), revealing interesting phenomena in the near-field region, such as optical scattering from surface defects or dust (fig. 8).

Figs. 6 and 7: Evanescent wave measurement.
Evanescent wave measurement 1 Evanescent wave measurement 2
Fig. 6 Fig. 7

Fig. 6: Measurement of the amplitude of the evanescent field generated via TIR at a clean glass/air interface. The interface lies approximately in the z=0 plane.
Fig. 7: This evanescent field can be detected out to a distance of approximately one micron (femto-Watt regime) before noise starts to become a significant problem.


Fig. 8 A scan of a region above a surface that exhibits scattering points.
Amplitude of evanescent field Phase of evanescent field
(a) (b)

Fig. 8: Near to the surface the amplitude (a) of the evanescent field dominates, and the measured phase (b) correlates with an evanescent wave. Further away, the amplitude of propagating components is now more prevalent, leading to phase information that describes propagation of scattered light away from the surface.


By mathematically adding a phase term in the reference arm, we can see the propagation of the light due to the scattering in the z-direction and the evanescent wavefront in the x-direction (movie 1).

Movie 1: Evolution of the isophase for varying values of reference relative phase. Indicates wave propagation.
Evolution of the isophase

After plane wave and evanescent wave detection, another test is also a source of interest: the evanescent standing wave (Figs. 9 (amplitude) and 10 (phase)). In fact, the interference of two evanescent waves, with opposite directions, allows our instrument to be characterised. Evanescent standing waves are a useful test "structure" because no topographical defect perturbs the detection (tip-surface forces).

Figs. 9 and 10: Evanescent standing wave measurement.
Evanescent standing wave measurement (amplitude) Evanescent standing wave measurement (phase)
Fig. 9 Fig. 10

Fig. 9: Evanescent standing wave field created by illuminating a prism surface in TIR using two input beams coming from opposite directions. The scan is in a single plane (x-y) parallel to the prism surface. The resulting field exhibits periodically spaced regions of high and low amplitude (time-averaged), expected for a standing wave field.
Fig. 10: The phase distribution for this field. The neighbouring regions of high amplitude, separated by lines of near-zero amplitude, are always of opposite phase.


Amplitude and phase measurement of the sinusoidal modulation of the field enables investigation of the possible limitations of the device. Optical amplitude and phase changes with a resolution of 1.6 nm are presented in fig. 11.

Fig. 11: (a) A cross-section of one of the amplitude 'troughs' of fig. 9.
(b) The corresponding phase. In both plots changes can be seen over the step size of 1.6 nm.
Cross section of amplitude Corresponding phase
(a) (b)

Optical fields emerging from gratings

One important goal of this work is the understanding of the interaction of light with microstructures. Even if the structure features are on the micron scale, the diffracted fields have sub-wavelength features. Sub-wavelength resolution measurements of the amplitude and phase of the optical fields generated by a micron pitch grating are shown in fig. 12. The Talbot effect, which is a representation of the grating at periodic distances, is also observed. The measurement has been made over a plane of 5 by 10 microns, demonstrating the high stability achieved with this apparatus.

Fig. 12: Diffraction grating measurement.
Diffraction grating measurement Diffraction grating measurement (phase)
(a) (b)

Fig. 12: (a) Periodic nature of the field generated by a diffraction grating.
(b) Corresponding phase map. Phase remains very stable over the large area scanned, indicating high stability of the equipment. The scan was finished when the tip finally touched the sample, leading to distortion of the field for the values of z near the surface.


By zooming in on a region of fig. 12, we can compare the calculation made with the Fourier Modal Method (fig. 13 a) with the measured phase (fig. 13 b).

Fig. 13 Comparison of theory (a) with experiment (b).
Theory Experiment
(a) (b)

We especially pay attention to the phase distribution behind the grating. Here, the interaction of light with microstructures gives birth to phase singularities. These special points, where the intensity vanishes, are a great source of interest. In fact, their position in space can give information on the original structure. The position of phase singularities has been measured with high resolution, even in the far-field, within 10 nm (Fig. 14).

Fig. 14: (a) Cross-section of amplitude through a phase singularity (S).
(b) Corresponding phase step. Ideally, the amplitude falls to zero for an infinitely small distance. In reality, a rapid fall to a lower value is seen between points A and B.
Amplitude through a phase singularity Corresponding phase step
(a) (b)

One interesting behaviour of the phase distribution has been observed: during the propagation of the wavefront, the phase turns around the phase singularities, which remain at a fixed position. If the two phase singularities are close to each other, the phase turns with opposite directions around the phase singularity (movie 2).

Movie 2: Evolution of wavefronts with time.
Evolution of wavefronts with time

Finally, we can see the propagation of the optical field behind a grating (1 micron pitch) in movie 3 which represents the amplitude multiplied by the cosine of the phase.

Movie 3: Propagation of the optical field above the grating.
Propagation of the optical field

The measurement of the amplitude and phase in optical fields with sub-wavelength features has been demonstrated, opening a new area of research in nano-optics. In fact, such an instrument can be utilised in different domains. In future, we hope that coherent scanning probes can aid us in the understanding and the fabrication of optical nano-structures, such as photonic bandgap waveguides used in telecommunication devices.


back IMT - Applied Optics' Home Page
back IMT Home Page
back University of Neuchâtel Home Page


Webmaster/ IMT - Applied Optics / University of Neuchâtel